Just as donnes love poems are filled with religious imagery, so his holy sonnets are intensely romantic, even erotic. A play, by margaret edson an fantastic pulitzer prize winning play about a john donne scholar diagnosed with cancer. Emma thompson reads death be not proud by john donne. However, two editions published shortly after donnes death include the sonnets in a different order, where this poem appears as eleventh in the songs and sonnets published 1633 and sixth in divine meditations published 1635. Death be not proud is a 1949 memoir by american journalist john gunther. It catches the readers attention because of its bold and defiant address of death. Death be not proud john donne death, be not proud, though some have called thee mighty and dreadful, for thou art not so. A short analysis of john donnes death, be not proud. I know, i know, i still need to get the cast names in there and ill be eternally tweaking it, so if you have any corrections, feel free to drop me a line. One of the books strengths, in fact, is not only its judicious use of commentary from. She drolly states that in grand rounds, they read me like a book. Sonnet x, also known by its opening words as death be not proud, is a fourteenline poem.
In addition to the stage production, we also have in an hbo special dramatization that starred emma thompson. Starring emma thompson as professor vivian bearing, who undergoes experimental treatment for stage four metastatic ovarian cancer, the 2001 film is based on the 1998 play by margaret edson. Get an answer for emma thompson john donne what links between john donnes death, be not proud and emma thompsons wit and find homework. Facing her own death, donnes poems, and particularly death be not proud, take on new meaning for her.
Death, be not proud emma thompson in wit 2001 ive watched this movie twice in the last 24 hours. Emma thompson s most popular book is romeo and juliet. A short analysis of john donnes death, be not proud interesting. Also, the rest that death offers can be obtained from sleep or drugs poppy. For the memoir by john gunther, see death be not proud book. Its one thing to finish a book thinking, it didnt have to end that way, its another not to have any sympathy at all for anyone but a secondary, prop character. Finally, the wit script is here for all you quotes spouting fans of the emma thompson hbo movie about cancer. He is the author of, among others, the secret library. Donne wrote sonnet x, death be not proud, while he was fighting a major illness that brought him close to death.
In death, be not proud the relevant conceit is that death is being compared to a boastful, but not very impressive, man. Emma thompson has 39 books on goodreads with 16258 ratings. Death, be not proud holy sonnet 10 introduction shmoop. Not because its about a woman with cancer but because all of my lady friends will get something out of it. Death be not proud had me right back in the enthralling and mysterious stories of emma and matthew, with more tantalising revelations about the secrets in both their families lives, the past and the present, set against the vivid backgrounds of historic england and the snowcovered winter in maine. Please discuss the paradox in the last two lines of john. An excerpt from the holy sonnet x death be not proud by john donne as read by emma thompson in the movie wit, the song is spiegel im spiegel by arvo part. This script is a transcript that was painstakingly transcribed using the screenplay andor viewings of wit.
See more ideas about john donne, john donne poems and metaphysical poetry. At the end of the play, and of her life, vivian is responding not to donne but to the childrens book the runaway bunny, by margaret wise brown. English professor vivian bearing thompson is an uncompromising authority on 17th century english poetry, especially that of john donne, whose holy sonnet x death, be not proud. Nor even because recent events in my life have brought home to me, again, just how fragile the people in our lives are. Although the drama is, in many ways, an uncompromisingly serious look at death, it also shows how language and humor can help deal with tragedy, even that our own impending death. The only possible bad thing to be said about wit is that ive yet to find it available in region 2. Owens dulce et decorum est, a poem that is about how war is in no way glamorous. Arguing over life, death, and a semicolon better living through.
Death be not proud the secret of the journal book 2. Death, be not proud, though some have called thee mighty and dreadful, for thou art not so. Death be not proud presents an argument against the power of death. Death be not proud is probably donnes bestknown poem. This paper analyzes both the play and the hbo special dramatization of margaret edsons pulitzer prize winning drama wit, inspired by her work as an. Wit is a 2001 american television movie directed by mike nichols. Death be not proud tenth holy sonnet by john donne in. Death, be not proud an indepth look at wit wit is margaret edison s 1999 pulitzer prizewinning play about a middleaged woman diagnosed with ovarian cancer. Death also should not be proud because its companions are poison, war, and sickness. Nor should death be proud, certainly not of ovarian cancer. Ultimately, the fact that the souls delivery is not in the hands of death is the reason it should not be proud. Death, cancer, john donne, salvation, grace, humility, humanity, growth, knowledge. This collection of his holy sonnets often called the westmoreland sequence contains 19 sonnets written by donne from his conversion to anglicanism up until his death.
Arguing over life, death, and a semicolon better living. In 2001, director mike nichols and actressscreenwriter emma thompson joined forces to bring this unflinchingly honest story to the small screen. An excerpt from the holy sonnet x death be not proud by john donne as read by emma thompson in the movie wit, the song is spiegel. And what came to me was john donnes poem, death, be not proud. An fantastic pulitzer prize winning play about a john donne scholar diagnosed with cancer. Sonnet x, also known by its opening words as death be not proud, is a fourteenline poem, or sonnet, by english poet john donne 15721631, one of the leading figures in the metaphysical poets of seventeenthcentury english literature. These are metaphysical poems that deal with divine love, death, penance, his own grievances, and obviously. The teleplay by nichols and emma thompson is based on the 1999 pulitzer prize winning play. This play was also turned into a great movie starring emma thompson. A collection of critical essays, by helen gardner gardner is one of. Today i am hungering for the day when there will be no more cancer and no more need for chemo and radiation. Death be not proud, though some have called thee mighty and dreadful, for, thou art not so. In the poem, he argues, for all kinds of reasons, that death is nothing to fear.
Death, be not proud holy sonnet 10 audio, video, music. What follows is the poem, followed by a short introduction to it, including an analysis of its more interesting. It was shown at the edinburgh film festival and the warsaw film festival later. The professor of irony and paradox learns to read the suffering text of her own body. Dulce et decorum est, a poem that is about how war is in no way glamorous. The book describes the decline and death of gunthers son, johnny, due to a brain tumor. Emma thompsons character, vivian bearing, recites the poem in wit, where john donne plays a central role. The teleplay by nichols and emma thompson is based on the 1999 pulitzer prize winning play of the same title by margaret edson the film was shown at the berlin international film festival on february 9, 2001 before being broadcast by hbo on march 24.
I am unable to find the proper version of it online. I showcase this sonnet with clips from emma thompson in wit. These thoughts merge in my post today, john donnes holy sonnet, death be not proud, and emma thompson s stunning work as an english professor grappling with the issues of cancer, death, and life in the movie wit. There, john donnes holy sonnet 10 death, be not proud played a great part.
Charles still i think arthur hill and robby benson when i think of that poem as hill played john gunther who wrote a book about his son ricky. In this poem, one of his most celebrated holy poems, death is personified as a male braggart, like a soldier boasting of all the men hes slain. Its not funny and sweet, like i prefer my entertainment most of the time. Donnes poem is one of his few holy sonnets that might actually be called optimistic. Professorturnedpatient vivian bearing emma thompson in the hbo. Wit script transcript from the screenplay andor emma. Even with her sharp wit, she learns that she is like everyone else. A brief summary and analysis of one of john donnes classic holy sonnets the sonnet death, be not proud is one of the most famous holy sonnets written by john donne 15721631. The sonnet death, be not proud is one of the most famous holy. And not a poem, exactly, but a relatively recent reading by an actor who can make the phone book sound good. A few months before his death, john donne commissioned this portrait of himself as he. Emma thompson john donne what links between john donnes. The book describes the decline and death of gunthers son, johnny, due to a brain. Death be not proud the secret of the journal book 2 ebook.
You have entirely missed the point of the poem, because, i must tell you, you have used an edition of. I would suggest that it is not only emma thompson s most moving performance to date, which is quite a feat, but also probably the only fictional film i have seen which i am not ashamed to say i sobbed over. As a slight aside, if you havent seen the play or the film wit starring, in the film version, emma thompson, which tells the story of a donne scholar dying from ovarian cancer, i suggest you rush off and see it. Thefilmed version of the play wit, starring emma thompson, is, as i remember it, both harrowing and inspiring. Donne addresses the personified figure of death as if it were a man hed. What is death, be not proud holy sonnet 10 about and why should i care.
1436 1199 613 714 228 790 92 1338 1505 334 331 1045 692 16 633 925 1007 721 681 730 1353 255 244 321 414 150 388 245 788 774 680 624